Coin Grading – Get it Right the First Time You Invest!
By Greg Locke
The value of a coin is generally determined by three factors, rarity, demand and condition. Amateur coin collectors and investors are easily able to determine if a coin has rarity or demand, few could say they are knowledgeable in determining the condition of a coin. Condition is everything when two like coins compete for best price, would you buy the MS 63 Penny or the VF Penny?
The information below will help you navigate your way to a basic understanding of coin grading. Get yourself two or three coins and grade them according to either of the following scales:
The most basic coin grading scale and the one most regularly used at online auctions:
Gem Uncirculated – Full mint lustre, virtually flawless strike, any detracting marks are insignificant, great eye appeal & beautiful fields.
UNC -Uncirculated – Good eye appeal, no significant detracting marks, may have some insignificant bagging, good strike and should have lustre present. No damage to the rim.
EF – Extra Fine – Lightly worn on the high points only. Usually has been withdrawn from circulation early. Still has some lustre and should have very good eye appeal. Insignificant rim marks only.
VF – Very Fine – Has obvious wear to the high points of the coin through considerable circulation. Rim shows some light damage / marks. The coin pattern should still be crisp and most importantly, the coin should look good to the eye. Traces of lustre present.
F – Fine – Well circulated coin with extensive wear on the design. Average at best.
VG – Very Good – You can just make out the date and design, nearly all other pattern detail is gone.
If you are after a more accurate picture this is the Grading system used by professional coin grading companies. It is called the Sheldon System and provides a more detailed description. Many rare Australian coins are sent to companies like PCGS in the USA, returning with a grade from this system.
Poor – 1 A coin in this condition can just be identified; its date and detail may be completely worn, the coin is usually has a smooth flat surface.
Fair – 2 A coin in fair condition may have the date and half the major detail faintly recognisable, mostly a smooth, flat coin.
Good (G-4) This coin will be heavily worn, its major detail weak. The main designs will be recognisable.
Very Good (VG-8) Most of the major detail visible but heavily worn.
Fine (F-12) Finer Detail is visible though worn heavily, major detail apparent.
Very Fine (VF-20) A coin in this condition should have a moderate even wear and all major features should be visible.
Extremely Fine (XF-40) This coin should have traces of mint lustre. There should be slight wear on the high points of many designs.
About Un-circulated (AU-50) Mint lustre will be evident. There will be faint traces of wear in the highest points. All other high points should be clearly visible, while showing no wear in the design on the lower areas.
Mint State (MS-60) Completely un-circulated condition. Excellent lustre – though it may not be evident across all fields. The coin may have a few marks, a natural result from minting and transportation.
Mint State (MS-65) Full mint lustre on all of the coin’s surfaces. No detracting marks at all.
Mint State (MS-70) Perfect!
It all seems like a bit much at first but it’s easiest if you start at the top and work down to determine a coin’s grade. For example if your coin has detracting marks it will be below MS 65, faint traces of wear and it will be below MS 60.
Coin grading is an essential skill and very contentious when Investors / Collectors disagree on a coin’s grade. It can mean hundreds, thousands and even millions of dollars difference to the value of a coin. It is quite well known that many investors send their coins to grading companies several times over in the hope of a better outcome.
Learn more at www.dollarmule.com.au.
Article Source: Coin Grading – Get it Right the First Time You Invest!
 | Liquid Metals UK 1 oz .999 Fine Silver Bullion Bar "Resurrection Slab" 13-20 £ 63.10 |
 | 2026 SMI Fire Horse 1oz .999 Silver Colourised OMP Slab – Rare UK Lunar Series £ 120.00 |
 | 2026 American Eagle 1oz silver West point mint NY in presentation slab £ 81.30 |
 | 2025 American Silver Eagle 1oz 0.999 Silver coin NGC MS 69 Slab £ 76.62 |
 | 2025 fine silver 1oz Krugerrand coin slabbed. £ 69.34 |
 | 1 x Count Dracula 2025 1oz .999 Silver Bullion Coin In Slab £ 68.30 |
 | 1935 Solid Silver George V Jubilee medal .Slabbed/graded .High grade at MS64 £ 165.00 |
 | Roman Silver Denarius of Titus – Elephant Reverse –Colosseum – NGC Slabbed £ 394.30 |